The Social Studio New York

Perspectives  ·  01

Differentiation at the top of a category

Below a certain level, a business can win by being better. Above it, the competition is also good, and the decision moves somewhere else.

Mikki MohadebPositioning · Consumer psychology

There is a point in most categories where the product stops being the argument.

Below it, the differences are obvious and easy to describe. One kitchen is better than the one down the street. One garment is cut properly and another is not. At that level a business can win by being straightforwardly better, and much of the marketing writes itself, because there is something concrete to point at.

Above that point the picture changes. The competition is also good. The materials are comparable, the people are experienced, the reviews are strong on both sides. Someone choosing between two options at the top of a category is rarely choosing between quality and the absence of it. They are choosing between two things that would both be fine.

This is the position most of the businesses we work with are in, and it is usually why they come to us. Very little is wrong with what they make. What is unresolved is why someone should choose it over the other good option.

What the decision is actually about

When the functional difference narrows, the decision moves. It moves toward what the brand represents, and toward whether a person can place themselves in it.

That is less abstract than it sounds. Most purchases above a certain price carry a social meaning alongside the practical one. Where someone takes a client to dinner says something about how they want to be seen in that relationship. What someone wears says something about who they understand themselves to be. The object is real and the meaning attached to it is also real, and near the top of a category the meaning is frequently the part doing the deciding.

A business that has settled what it represents gives a buyer something to recognise. One that has not settled it offers a good product and leaves the recognition to chance. Both may be excellent. Only one of them is easy to choose.

The product has to be good. Past a certain point, being good is the condition for entering the decision rather than the thing that wins it.

Why this is a positioning problem before it is a design one

The usual response to a differentiation problem is a visual one. A new logo, a new palette, better photography. Those decisions matter, and we make them, but they sit downstream. A visual identity can express a position. It cannot establish one. When the question of what the business means has not been answered, a redesign produces a more attractive version of the same ambiguity, and the ambiguity is what the customer was responding to.

The work that establishes it is less immediately satisfying. It involves deciding what the business believes, who it is actually for, what it will not do, and where it stands against the specific companies it is being compared with. That is a set of arguments rather than a set of aesthetics. It has to be settled before the visual language can be anything more than tasteful.

Tasteful is not a small thing. It is also not a differentiator, because at the top of a category everyone is working with people who have taste.

Where it becomes visible

Once a position is genuinely settled, it stops being an internal document and turns into a long series of ordinary decisions.

It decides what gets photographed and what is left out of frame. It decides what the business says first on a page and what it never says anywhere. It decides which collaborations make sense and which would read as borrowed. It decides whether a reduction is announced loudly, quietly, or not at all. Each of those is minor on its own. Together they are most of what a customer is actually reading.

This is also why the difference between a resolved brand and an unresolved one is rarely visible in any single piece of work. Compare one photograph against another and they may be equally good. Compare a year of decisions and one of them has accumulated into something a person can describe to a friend, while the other has produced a large quantity of competent material that adds up to an impression nobody can summarise.

The part that holds under pressure

There is a further reason to do this work, and it shows up when a category gets crowded or when a competitor starts competing on price.

A business differentiated only by quality has a narrow set of responses available when a cheaper option appears that is nearly as good. It can argue about specifications, which most buyers are not equipped to evaluate, or it can meet the price, which removes the premium it was built on.

A business attached to something beyond the product has more room. A history, a place, a particular point of view, a standard it is known for holding. Those are not available to a competitor at any price, because they were accumulated rather than purchased. This is the part of brand work that reads as soft until the moment it is the only thing left holding the position.

A practical test

A reliable way to find out whether this is resolved is to ask several people inside the business, separately, who the brand is for and what it stands for.

If the answers differ only in wording, the position exists and the task is to express it more precisely. If they differ in substance, it has not been set, and no amount of output will compensate. The content calendar will keep producing work, each piece defensible, and the brand will keep reading as a collection of decisions made by different people on different days.

The answer does not have to be elaborate. It has to be decided, and it has to be the same answer in every place a person encounters the business.

Mikki Mohadeb

Founder & Creative Director, The Social Studio

More

Contact

Work with The Social Studio.

We work across identity development, brand strategy, creative campaigns, and ongoing social media management. Schedule an introductory consultation to discuss your objectives and explore a potential collaboration.

Or email thesocialstudiony@gmail.com